November 7, 2017 11:18:22 AM
The contents of this article have been modified since its original posting.
While the city of Columbus will not be immediately releasing body camera footage that captured a police officer shooting and killing a local man outside a nightclub on Saturday morning, multiple sources who have seen the video have told The Dispatch what it shows.
According to those sources, who asked to remain anonymous because they are not authorized to speak about an ongoing investigation, the footage shows Patrolman Jared Booth arriving to the scene at about 1 a.m. and approaching a security guard at Premier Lounge on 22nd Street South to ask about a reported disturbance.
Two shots ring out, and Booth runs across the street to find two men trying to wrestle a gun away from 24-year-old Raymond Davis. Booth twice yells, "Get the f*** down," after which the two other men let go of Davis.
Davis then spins to his left, approximately 270 degrees, until he's facing Booth with the barrel of the gun pointing in the direction of the officer.
Booth then fires more than once. The sources said they heard six shots on the footage, but it is unclear whether Davis fired any of them.
The sources also noted a white car on the scene already showed a bullet hole before Booth fired.
About 11 seconds lapsed between the time Booth heard the first two shots in the distance and the time he shot Davis, the sources said.
Booth was the only officer on scene at the time, according to the sources.
CPD policy says officers can use deadly force "when it appears to be reasonably necessary" and specifies its use as: a means of self-defense from death or serious injury; to defend the life of another officer; to defend the life of a victim of a crime; to prevent a crime in which human life is in serious jeopardy as a result of the suspect's actions; or to apprehend a fleeing suspect for a crime involving the use of deadly force or whose escape would cause an imminent threat to society.
Between city officials, the overview committee and the Pastors on Patrol group, about 30 people have seen the body camera footage.
Video to not be publicly released yet
City leaders, including Mayor Robert Smith, met Monday with District Attorney Scott Colom and a representative with the Mississippi Bureau of Investigation -- the agency handling the case. On Sunday, Smith and Police Chief Oscar Lewis said they would ask in that meeting if they could publicly release at least part of body camera footage.
The answer apparently was no.
"We're just not going to be able to do that right now unless some people change their minds," City Attorney Jeff Turnage told The Dispatch. "It falls under (exemptions) to the Freedom of Information Act entitled 'investigative reports.' ... Releasing it might reveal the identities of witnesses, it might affect (MBI's) ability to investigate and it could ultimately keep someone from getting a fair trial."
Smith and city council members viewed the body camera footage in executive session of a special-call meeting Sunday evening. Then the Columbus Police Department Citizen Overview Committee viewed the footage in its own executive session.
In a press conference following those two meetings, Smith announced Booth had activated his body camera when he was called to the scene of a large disturbance at the club, and that Davis had a gun in his hand when Booth shot him.
Davis was pronounced dead less than an hour later at Baptist Memorial Hospital-Golden Triangle. A woman sitting in a nearby car who was hit by a stray bullet in the incident was treated at the hospital and released, city officials said.
Colom, speaking with The Dispatch, said he felt the council acted appropriately by watching the video and allowing the overview committee to watch it, as well.
But he defended the decision to withhold the video from public view until after the investigation is over.
Once the investigation ends, the case file will go to Colom to present to a grand jury, which will determine whether to indict (formally charge) Booth.
"When dealing with these types of situations, MBI has to protect the integrity of the investigation and make sure there's not too much information released too soon," Colom said. "Because if too much is released too soon, it affects our ability to find an impartial grand jury -- or later a (trial) jury (if necessary) -- to make independent decisions."
Warren Strain, public affairs director for the Mississippi Department of Public Safety -- which oversees MBI -- told The Dispatch Monday afternoon he wasn't aware of the city's press conference or its request to release the footage.
He agreed, though, the footage needs to remain a sealed part of the investigatory file for now.
"This investigation is being done in an impartial, thorough and methodical way," Strain said. "We don't want things to play out in the public domain until the appropriate time. We just ask for the public's patience while we work through it."
Strain said the investigation was in the "early stages" and would not comment to The Dispatch on any of its details.
Editor's note: The story has been updated to clarify that, according to sources, Davis' gun was pointed in the direction of Booth.
Zack Plair is the managing editor for The Dispatch.
1. Man charged with attempted murder for using vehicle as weapon COLUMBUS & LOWNDES COUNTY
2. Starkville looking to change panhandling law STARKVILLE & OKTIBBEHA COUNTY
4. Man busted for marijuana trafficking STARKVILLE & OKTIBBEHA COUNTY
5. Learning to lead: Mayor's Youth Council boasts record 54 members this year COLUMBUS & LOWNDES COUNTY